Gibraltar Chronicle Logo
Opinion & Analysis

A hint of drama at the end of a quiet, clean campaign

In his victory speech earlier this morning, Chief Minister Fabian Picardo made no effort to disguise the scale of the challenges ahead for this community.
He was referring in large part to Brexit, of course. The GSLP/Liberal Alliance secured its third term against the backdrop of upheaval in British politics. Prime Minister Boris Johnson, who against the odds this week secured a withdrawal agreement from the EU, will now struggle to get it through the House of Commons on Saturday. He faces tough opposition there and the Brexit question mark, for now at least, remains.
But Mr Picardo was also looking north, reminding voters that the “tectonic movements” in Spain, a reference not just to the political deadlock in Madrid but to the violence in Catalonia, would also reverberate here.
And he had a domestic message too, one that signals a rethink on how Gibraltar handles many of its internal affairs. “The age of entitlement,” he said, “is over. It is time for the age of responsibility, the age of sustainability.”
Yesterday’s vote represents a ringing endorsement for the Alliance, not just on issues such as Brexit but on the work done domestically too.
The drama on election night was largely on the Opposition bench, where Together Gibraltar’s Marlene Hassan Nahon topped the list ahead of the veterans on the GSD slate by 771 votes.

GSD stalwarts pointed to an element of tactical voting by GSLP/Liberal backers who gave Ms Hassan Nahon a vote and dropped the less popular candidates on the Alliance slate, and there may be some truth to that.
But Ms Hassan Nahon, who started her parliamentary career with the GSD only to leave six months later to become an Independent and form TG, clearly also won a fair share of hearts and minds through hard work and passionate discourse.
She may have been helped too by the GSD’s policy on abortion, which some in that party believe may have lost them support from younger voters.
The result represents a major achievement for a third party but, above all, for Ms Hassan Nahon as an individual. Breaking into Parliament in TG’s maiden election heralds well for the party, although the goal now will be to maintain momentum. On her own in Parliament, Ms Hassan Nahon will require commitment and support from her team outside, and that will be their biggest challenge over the next four years. But this morning, true to form, she was feisty in summing up her position.
“The next Together Gibraltar election campaign starts today,” she said.
Yet despite their Leader’s sterling performance and bullish attitude to the future, there was disappointment too in the TG camp, where expectations had been high that the party would secure several seats in Parliament. There was tension through the night as Craig Sacarello appeared set to slip into the 17th slot, nudging another GSD candidate out of the running. In the end though, he missed out to Edwin Reyes by a mere 35 votes.

For the GSD, the result of the election was a mixed bag. At one level, the loss of an MP is a blow to the party, which together with the Alliance has dominated local politics for three decades. While the party had publicly campaigned as an alternative to the Alliance in government, in private the goal was to ensure it emerged with seven seats in Parliament.
But a different reading of the result is that the GSD clearly retains a core vote and has seen off, for the most part, the immediate threat from TG. Third parties have never, at least in recent times, managed to break through into Parliament, but Ms Hassan Nahon had an advantage, having started the election with four years as an MP under her belt. That helped turbo-charge TG’s campaign, making it an even bigger threat to the GSD. It could have been worse, in other words.
But Keith Azopardi was clearly deflated this morning, not just with his party’s result but also with his personal showing. He came third in the GSD ranking behind Damon Bossino and Daniel Feetham and, while the difference in votes was relatively slim, that result will fuel speculation about the future of his leadership, not least because under the GSD’s constitution, a Leader who fights and loses an election must have his or her position reconfirmed by the membership within a year of the election. Mr Azopardi called this a “no change election”, but the reality is that, while the parliamentary make-up of the parties has not changed, there was one significant shift. At the last election, the GSD won seven seats, including Ms Hassan Nahon’s. This time round, it was down to six.
Time will tell whether the party rallies round Mr Azopardi, whose political presence will be boosted hugely now that he is back inside Parliament, or whether any of the other candidates might fancy their chances. For now though, Mr Azopardi has vowed to regain the confidence of voters in the GSD and revitalise a party who some people had written off, but which this December celebrates 30 years in existence and whose political obituary, he said today, “was premature”.
The vote brought to a close a quiet, clean campaign that had focused on issues and policies, not personalities.
This morning as the result was declared by Returning Officer Paul Martinez, all three party leaders vowed to work together when necessary to defend the collective interests of this community. That is a wise decision, because Gibraltarian voters love nothing more than to see their politicians present a united front to external challenges.
But a vital ingredient of that united front is trust, and that is hard won.
Mr Azopardi promised “constructive and sometimes difficult opposition” and asked for “reciprocity and real involvement” on issues such as Brexit. Mr Picardo said he would work with the Opposition in “parliamentary partnership” but asked for “generosity and maturity” in exchange, “not spite in defeat as we have seen in the past”.
As the Brexit storm clouds loom ever closer, we will see how those commitments hold up.

Most Read

Download The App On The iOS Store